Skip to content

Authors Asked to Erase Gay Character.

September 20, 2011

Stop discrimination

You’re a writer, you have worked hard on developing a plot for your young adult, fictional novel. You have created a character you love and you know will reach out to your readership. The excitement builds as you get a call from a literary agent who says they love the book but… for the manuscript to be more palatable to the publishers they want you to write out the black character and make him white. The outcry would be huge, with such an idea hitting the six O clock news. Yet it was only twenty years ago when children’s author Malorie Blackman was asked to do just that.

 So when she was told that last week, two American writers, Sherwood Smith and Rachel Manija Brown, were told by a literary agent that their young adult, post-apocalyptic novel, Stranger, was of interest, but only on the proviso that they re-wrote the gay characters as a heterosexual couple; her adamant response was, “Are we still not over this nonsense? When I was asked [to whiten her character] I said no. It seems to me this is more of the same … With all these things it stems from ignorance, and ignorance breeds fear. A good way of tackling this is to show gay or Muslim or black characters in our fiction for children.”  Thankfully Smith and Brown refused the offer, saying; “When you refuse to allow major characters in young adult  novels to be gay, you are telling gay teenagers that they are so utterly horrible that people like them can’t even be allowed to exist in fiction.”

To think that this was an isolated case by a rogue agent would ease things, but there have been many other authors who have come forward, speaking out about similar experiences of being asked to erase their LGBT characters and replace them with heterosexual characters.  Jessica Verday, faced similar discrimination with the characters she had created for the, Wicked Pretty Things, trilogy; again the publishers wanted to turn the gay relationship straight. Rather than give into the publishers demands, Verday walked away from the project saying, “Wesley and Cameron’s story isn’t an agenda or an issue. It isn’t an “I have to prove something to the world” story. Wesley and Cameron’s story is a love story. About one boy who loves another boy so much that when something bad happens to him, he’ll do whatever it takes to get him the help he needs.”

Now, envisage how much better it would have been for all of us growing up, knowing inside that we were different from our heterosexual friends, if an author like Verday was around. Imagine then if we could have picked up a book that the majority of our friends were reading and there was a main character who was either lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender. How fantastic it would have felt if that book had a LGBT character in it whose friends and family had no hang ups about their sexuality, and they just got into the same adventures as their straight counterparts…What a difference J.K. Rowling could have made to her young teenage LGBT readers if she had decided that either Harry, Ron or Hermione identified themselves as either gay, bisexual, lesbian or transgender. Who knows, perhaps she did, but the publishers stepped in and said you can have a token gay character once the public are onboard with the series…hmmm.   

I doubt such archaic ideas on sexuality in young adult’s fiction are going to be cracked right away, but by speaking out supporting those writers who understand that the world we live in is filled with an array of different characters is a step forward in stamping out yet another incident of causal homo/lesbian/bisexual/transphobia.

 

 

 

 

Advertisements
11 Comments
  1. Well siad, Glenn. I note that on Goodreads, the vast majority of comments on Wicked Pretty Things are along the lines of “Jessica eventually backed out because the publishers wouldn’t move on the issue – I refuse to buy or read this”. It is now rated lower than Mein Kampf.

    I hope the publishers learn something…

    • Thanks for the comment logicelf, let’s hope the publishers living in the dark ages wake up and realise just how backward there thinking is.

  2. Keir Bottrill permalink

    Well done, Glenn. keep up the good work,
    Keir.

  3. Thank’s Keir, glad you liked the piece.

  4. Excellent piece Glenn. Very well written.
    Drew

  5. Thank You Drew, Glad you liked the piece.

  6. Well, J, K. Rowling did write a main character as homosexual. As is typical, and appropriate for educators, he just didn’t flaunt his sexuality. Details here: http://www.the-leaky-cauldron.org/2007/10/20/j-k-rowling-at-carnegie-hall-reveals-dumbledore-is-gay-neville-marries-hannah-abbott-and-scores-more

    • Dear Shawn,
      Thank you for the link, my point I’m making is that a character ‘comes out’ only when there is a large (huge) readership for the series. Unlike the other authors who wished to have a main LGBT character at the very start. It would seem that some main publishers feel that to do so would put off a lot of readers from investing in the book in the first place. I certainly wasn’t suggesting that a character needed to flaunt his sexuality, but to be visible in teenage fiction.

      • I’ve been thinking about this lately. I am a supporter of The Purple Letter campaign in BC (see http://purplelettercampaign.ca/about/ ) and because of this, I have had students come to me, just to ‘be’ somewhere safe. That showed me how important it is to be clearly accepting, and not just ‘neutral’ in this discussion. As an author, I can see this need for believable, age appropriate LGBT characters, but as a straight person, I don’t know that I could do the reality justice. I also wonder about ‘authentic voice.’

        However, I have LGB friends and family, and I suppose I could draft something and get their feedback…

  7. Ohh… really? You know, I hadn’t ever thought of this. Some of my main characters, including my favourite (Marni), are gay or bisexual and they’ve been published online & in print without editorial requests for change, but so far that’s all flash fiction; I hadn’t really thought about it being different with a book. Obviously, I’m thinking about it now.

  8. Thank you for your commnet Martha, great to hear you have had work published with out editors asking to de-sex your gay/bi charatcers. His hoping that any LGBT charatcers in your book are not asked to be erased.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: